AIR INDIA DEAL IS NOT A GAMBLE -- AIR INDIA IS SIA'S DEFENSIVE SHIELD THAT SINGAPOREANS FAIL TO SEE
The public commentary surrounding SIA investment in Air India has become highly reactive, shifting from valid commercial evaluation to a simplistic blame game, and some even drifted into nationalist and racial populism. So far, I do not see comments or posts with domain knowledge. All are just noises touching on surface issues and questions. The only exception is my own previous post India is sitting on a sweet spot in aviation industry Traditional financial analysis is a myopic and wrong approach here because SIA's 25.1% holdings in Air India is not a straight-off passive investment. That is precisely where all the noises are coming from. Almost everyone are led to think it's all about trying to capture a slice of India's booming market. That may be true of Vistara, but the game changed in 2024. You need use the macro-economic lens to see above the noise. I see two points being pushed consistently which I like to address here: 1. SIA has a dismal poor record of inves...